Yes, first debate down! I must say it was a bore. They didn't pounce at each other like the format of this debate was set up for. But I suppose that is a good thing for them to show their statesmanship! I won't bore you with details of the debate, and I will not go into the analysis either. I'll just point out a few things that seem obvious to me.
Generation Gaps:
We all know what their stands on issues, so put that aside, let's take a look at their appearances. What I see immediately is a "generation gap". I will admit that McCain looks really good for his age, but he IS 72 years old, even with makeup plastered on him, he still looks 72. No matter how much he tries to claim that he is a "Change Agent", that just doesn't cut it. He's recitation of the names of past Secretary of States, leaders of the Soviet Union, does show his experience, but also shows he's ancient. Unfortunately, his ideology doesn't change that fact either. He is the past.
Obama looked fresh and exuberant. (I do wish they would go easy on the make-up on him). Being a quarter of a century younger than McCain, he was well versed with the history of our politics and had no problem naming the names of our current and past world leaders. At 47, he does represent the younger and the future generation.
Body Language and Attitude:
McCain was fidgeting frequently and throughout the entire debate, he did not look at or make any eye contact with Obama. He looked crotchety as if standing in the same stage with Obama was degrading to him. The tone of his answers whether to the questions asked or directly to Obama was more than condescending. He looked un-sportsman like.
From my perspective, Obama was engaging, many times speaking to McCain with direct eye contact, but was ignored. His posture (you know how we yoga practitioners value postures!) was confident, firm, yet approachable. He was able to smile or laugh off when McCain cut him off or carried over time on the answers.
Catch Phrase:
McCain started most of his answers with "Senator Obama just doesn't understand...". We all know that he's trying to show that Obama is inexperienced and not ready to lead. My take is that he wants to show distinction between his policy and ideas from Obama. And that to me is divisive. On top of that it sounded patronizing.
Obama had repeated many time "Senator McCain is right..." or "I agree with Senator McCain...". I've heard that this drew some criticism from the democrats and I believed the McCain Camp has made an ad using these phrases already. Well, I think I understand why Obama is doing this. I think he is trying to show that there are common grounds that they can all work with, negotiate with, and maybe that's a way to find unity.
Yesterday I took a yoga workshop with my teacher and 2 other guest teachers. Rodney Yee was one of the guest teacher. He quoted Krishnamacharya saying that when we divide something into 2, there will be conflicts. He was using it as a reference for our body: that most people think of their body as the "right side" and the "left side". No matter how much we try to find balance to both side, the concept of this separateness makes us tug and pull our body that creates less integration between the 2. That sounds to me like our politics!
I've heard so much analysis about Obama from my favorite presidential historian: Doris Kearns Goodwin. She talked about one of Obama's true desires is to work across the party line and how he wants to unite the country. He is willing to reach out to those who opposes him to bring unity, for example: how he reached out to the Clintons by giving them 2 prime time slots in the 2008 Denver Democratic Convention. Yet unfortunately, the nature of our election campaign is making it real hard for him to get that across. But we've all heard the speech he gave at Kerry's 2004 Convention. It still sends chills to my spine when I listen to it. (a clip of the 2nd half:)
Put aside all the differences or the commonalities between these 2 candidates, I know I definitely do not want a grumpy president who thinks the way to make America strong globally again is to make other countries fear us. We know how that turned out! We need a leader who is going to restore American's standing in the world by showing the good judgement, diplomacy, and integrity.
The choice is clear!